"ملف 1/A/38 II المفاوضات مع ابن سعود بخصوص الحدود الشرقية للمملكة العربية السعودية مع كلٍّ من قطر وعُمان المُتصالحة." [ظ‎‎٩‎٨] (٤٧٢/٢٠١)

'2
Mr Rendel pointed out that there was no legal obligation on a country having I
low tariffs to prevent smuggling into a country whose tariffs were high. The
problem was one of frequent occurrence and, to take an example on a very much I
larger scale, had occurred between His Majesty’s Government and the United
States Government in the days of prohibition in the United States. On that |
occasion His Majesty’s Government, though under no legal obligation to prevent
the export of liquor to the United States, had, in the interests of good lelations, j
voluntarily agreed to come to an arrangement under which they co-operated to
check liquor smuggling. In a small way the position was analogous m Koweit,
where the sheikh had now offered to co-operate for the purpose of checking
smu crc ding into Saudi Arabia. But it was quite impossible foi any country, e\en |
the most highly organised, to guarantee not to allow a single smugglei thiough, j
The Saudi Government’s demand could therefore only be described as |
unreasonable. Mr. Rendel regretted that the conference should have broken down
in this unsatisfactory manner when agreement appeared to have been reached on
the main problem. He wished to repeat that this question of Koweiti-Saudi |
relations was one to which His Majesty s Government attached particular JJ
importance. It was one of the main objects of His Majesty’s Government to ■
ensure that Saudi relations with Koweit should now be regularised and set right i
on the same lines as had been so successfully followed in the case of Saudi relations j
first with Iraq and then with Transjordan. He hoped, therefore, that Fuad Bey
might be able to arrange for the conference to be resumed.
Mr. LAITHWAITE also stressed the desire of the Secretary of State for
India and the Government of India to see this result achieved and the great j
importance which they attached to the disposal of the question. As regards the j
Saudi Government’s insistence on a guarantee, Mr. Laithwaite said that it seemed j
clear from the history of the last few years that the Saudi Government were |
in a position to impose an effective blockade on the land frontier of Koweit j
and to deal with any persons who might be caught smuggling across that land |
frontier That being so, a demand on Koweit for a guarantee such as had been
suggested would seem, to say the least of it, superfluous. He drew Fuad Bey’s
attention to the fact that if the Saudi Government’s demands were to be made
public they could not fail to show King Abdul Aziz in an invidious light, and||j
indeed might well give the impression that he was not really seeking a settlement.
Mr Laithwaite added that the Saudi delegates difficulties in negotiating, even j
with the help of the telegraph, were of course understood by His Majesty s
Government, but he reminded Fuad Bey that Koweit was ready to promise j|
on her honour to do her best to stop the smuggling, and he made it clear that I
His Majesty’s Government for their part would do all in their power to ensure I
that this undertaking was observed. He trusted therefore that Fuad Bey would 1
be able to suggest some way in which the Saudi Government could be induced to 1
relax their insistence on an absolute guarantee. I
FUAD BEY HAMZA, in reply, explained that, while the Saudi Legation
had received some information as to the progress of the negotiations at Koweit, I
they were not yet in possession of full details as to the points on which those |
negotiations had broken down. The information now given to him helped to
make the position clearer. He now understood that the following proposals had I
been made :— I
la) A svstem of customs posts through which trade would be canalised. I
{b) A system of manifests to be operated in conjunction with the system i
of customs posts. I
(c) An honourable undertaking by Koweit to do all she could to prevent
smuggling across the Saudi border. I
This having been confirmed, Fuad Bey undertook to make enquiries by tele
graph of his Government and expressed the hope that he would shortly be in a
position to make some statement on the matter.
At this point Mr. Laithwaite withdrew.
III.
The meeting then proceeded to discuss the future of the Treaty of Jedda
and the connected question of the suggested abandonment by His Majesty*
Government of their right of manumission.